Sign up here!

Valve replacements

Clinical examination

  • Metallic valves
    • Metallic mitral valve: S1 sounds metallic
    • Metallic aortic valve: S2 sounds metallic 
    • There is often a click audible without a stethoscope
  • Tissue valves
    • Relevant heart sounds may be normal, loud or quiet
  • Systolic flow murmurs are normal for aortic valve replacements
  • Assess for valve function (signs of regurgitation of replaced valve), cardiac decompensation (signs of heart failure), and signs of infective endocarditis
  • Also look for signs of over-anticoagulation (bruising) and anaemia (haemolysis)

Metallic mitral valve

Indications for surgery

  • Left-sided valve dysfunction 
    • Any valve: associated LVF, symptomatic
    • If regurgitation, also: acute onset, associated LV dilation
    • If mitral, also: presence of pulmonary hypertension

NB: for MR, valve repair is preferred when possible; for MS, balloon valvuloplasty is preferred unless contraindicated (i.e. coexistent MR, thrombus or calcified valve).

  • Infective endocarditis
    • Associated heart failure 
    • Uncontrolled infection (fistula, enlarging vegetation, false aneurysm, aortic root abscess, persistently positive blood cultures, fungal/multidrug-resistant organism)
    • High embolic risk (persistent large vegetation)

NB: If prosthetic valve, surgery also indicated if: <2 months post-op, valve dysfunction or Staphylococcus aureus infection.

Detail about valve types

Tissue valve

Usually porcine xenograft
Needs replacing after 10-15 years; sooner if patient is active
No need for warfarin
Recommended for older people, people with low life expectancy and females of child-bearing age

Mechanical valve

Longer lasting (older valves 20-30 years, newer valves >30 years)
Lifelong warfarin
Makes a quiet clicking noise
Recommended for younger people (<60 years) so they don’t need repeat surgeries (unless female and of child-bearing age because warfarin is teratogenic)


  • Pre-operative: transthoracic ± transoesophageal echo, coronary angiography 
  • May be performed by:
    • Open surgery: via midline sternotomy
    • Minimally invasive surgery
      • Aortic valve: via right anterior mini-thoracotomy (2nd intercostal space) or mini-sternotomy
      • Mitral valve: via right lateral mini-thoracotomy (below nipple or in breast crease)
  • Patient is put on cardiopulmonary bypass while valve is replaced

NB: if there is also coronary artery disease, CABG is usually performed concurrently – check the legs for a vein grafting scar.

Thoracic scars


Please list some complications of valve replacements?

Oops! This section is restricted to members.

Create an account or log in to continue reading.

Which bacteria commonly cause infective endocarditis?

Oops! This section is restricted to members.

Create an account or log in to continue reading.

What is a TAVI and when may this be indicated?

Oops! This section is restricted to members.

Create an account or log in to continue reading.

Try some OSCE stations

  1. Metallic aortic valve
  2. Metallic mitral valve
  3. More stations can be found here!
Join our email list!
For free OSCE tips and updates