Location: You are an FY1 in respiratory clinic
Patient: This patient has come for a check up. The consultant has asked you to examine the patient and present to them.
Task:
– Examine this patient’s respiratory system
– Please provide a running commentary whilst you are examining
– During the examination the examiner will present you with information to interpret
– After 6 minutes you will be asked a series of questions by the examiner.
| Mark sheet | π | π |
|---|---|---|
| Candidate appropriately introduced themselves with: | 3 | 4 |
| Examination etiquette | 3 |
Pass
Fail
Your percentage
Average user score for this station
Station pass mark
Feedback
A focused, systematic examination
- Introduce yourself, confirm the patientβs identity, explain the examination and obtain consent. Position them comfortably, usually at 45 degrees, with appropriate exposure and privacy. Give a concise running commentary that separates what you are checking from what you actually find.
- Start by assessing respiratory rate, work of breathing and any oxygen therapy. Then examine systematically, comparing corresponding areas on both sides during expansion, percussion and auscultation. Include the posterior chest and lung bases; ask the patient to breathe through an open mouth and allow pauses if they become breathless.
- Look beyond the lungs: clubbing can help identify chronic pulmonary disease, while a raised JVP and peripheral oedema may suggest pulmonary hypertension with right heart failure. These are signs to seek, not findings established in this patient.
Connecting the key findings
- The written station findings are digital clubbing and fine end-inspiratory crackles. Together, these support interstitial lung disease (ILD), particularly a fibrotic ILD. Fibrosis makes the lungs less compliant, reducing their ability to expand; late-inspiratory crackles are associated with reopening of small peripheral airways during inspiration.
- ILD is a diagnostic category, not a single cause. Idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis is a possibility, but examination alone cannot establish it. The next history should explore progressive exertional breathlessness, dry cough, occupational and environmental exposures, potentially causative medicines and connective tissue disease symptoms.
- Clubbing is not specific to ILD: bronchiectasis and lung malignancy are important alternatives. A productive cough with recurrent infections favours bronchiectasis. Heart failure can also cause inspiratory crackles, but orthopnoea and evidence of congestion would support that explanation; clubbing is not typical.
Interpreting the spirometry images
- Both attached images show the same volumeβtime spirometry diagram, not a flowβvolume loop. The volume expired at one second is the FEV1; the final plateau represents the forced vital capacity (FVC). There is no numerical volume scale, so exact values cannot be calculated.
- A, the green curve, is normal: it rises steeply and reaches a high plateau. B, the blue curve, represents obstruction: it rises more slowly, with delayed emptying and a disproportionately reduced FEV1, producing a reduced FEV1/FVC ratio.
- C, the orange curve, represents restriction and is the expected choice for this patient: it reaches a lower final volume. In a restrictive pattern, FEV1 and FVC are both reduced, with a preserved or increased ratio. Importantly, spirometry only suggests restriction; a reduced total lung capacity on full lung function testing confirms it.
Presenting and completing the assessment
- Keep the presentation centred on the positive findings: βThe patient has digital clubbing and fine end-inspiratory crackles, suggesting interstitial lung disease. I would assess oxygenation and arrange imaging and lung function testing to characterise this further.β Add other findings only if actually established.
- Check oxygen saturation, including exertional assessment when appropriate. An arterial blood gas can quantify hypoxaemia and assess carbon dioxide and acidβbase status, particularly if oxygenation is impaired. A chest X-ray provides an initial overview; high-resolution CT helps characterise the ILD pattern. Full lung function tests should include lung volumes and gas transfer, which is often reduced in ILD.
- Suspected ILD warrants respiratory specialist assessment. Follow-up considers symptoms, exercise tolerance, oxygenation and trends in FVC and gas transfer. New or rapidly worsening breathlessness or hypoxaemia needs prompt reassessment for complications such as infection, pulmonary embolism or an acute exacerbation, rather than being attributed automatically to gradual fibrosis.